The CD's Second Act: Who Is Still Buying Discs in the Streaming Era, and Why
Updated:
In mid-November 2026, Alliance Entertainment, a Florida-based wholesaler that sits between record labels, film studios and retail shelves, reported its first quarter of fiscal 2027 (the three months ended September 30, 2026). Total revenue rose 10% to $278.8 million. Compact-disc revenue grew fastest of any music format, up 22% to $41.2 million from $33.9 million. Vinyl climbed 14% to $86.7 million, and DVD and Blu-ray movie revenue rose 20% to $101.1 million, according to Media Play News. CEO Jeff Walker also said the company is running a 14-store test of vinyl and CD sections with Best Buy, which he hopes could expand to between 100 and 300 stores in 2027 (Digital Music News).

One distributor's quarter is a narrow window. Still, it lines up with what the industry's main data sources have shown all year. Years after streaming was supposed to finish it off, the CD is selling more again, mostly in the US, and buyers' reasons have little to do with sound quality. This article looks at who is buying, why, what the numbers actually measure, and whether DVDs really are next.
The Rebound, Measured Three Ways
Physical music statistics are easy to misread because different sources count different things. In the US, the RIAA reports what labels ship, at wholesale value and net of returns. Luminate counts units sold to consumers at retail. In the UK, the BPI reports trade revenue, while the Entertainment Retailers Association (ERA) reports what shoppers spent. The numbers below should be read with those differences in mind.
The US, full-year 2025: the CD had not turned yet. In its 2025 year-end report, the RIAA's first full-year report on a wholesale basis, CD revenue fell 7.8% to $312.4 million and units fell 11.6% to 29.5 million. Vinyl went the other way. It rose 9.3% to $1.04 billion on 46.8 million units, its 19th straight year of growth.
The US, first half of 2026: a sharp turn. The RIAA mid-year report shows CD shipments up 45.7% to 17.5 million units and CD revenue up 58.6% to $171.1 million, from $107.9 million a year earlier. Vinyl revenue grew 17.7% to $543.8 million on 26.5 million units. Total physical revenue rose 25.9% to $731.5 million, against total recorded-music revenue of $5.97 billion.
Luminate's consumer-sales data points the same way but is more modest. US CD sales rose 16% to 16.3 million units in the first half of 2026, while vinyl grew only 2.4%. With K-pop releases removed, CD sales still grew 6.7%. Vinyl still outsells the CD in absolute units, but by Luminate's count the CD's growth rate was roughly seven times vinyl's.
There are two reasons the RIAA figures look so much stronger. First, shipments can run ahead of sales when retailers add inventory, so wholesale and consumer data can diverge (this is the author's reading of the methodology gap, not a figure either source publishes). Second, the comparison base was weak: Stereogum, citing the RIAA's 2025 mid-year report, notes that CD sales were down 22% year over year at that point. Part of the 58.6% gain is a recovery from a dip.
The UK: a smaller version of the same story. The BPI says UK CD revenue grew 3.1% in 2025 to £99.6 million, after a 0.5% fall in 2024, giving the format its best year since 2021. Vinyl grew much faster, up 19.9% to £174.7 million, and now makes up 62.9% of UK physical revenue. Taylor Swift drove both formats. The Life of a Showgirl sold about 226,000 CDs in the UK in 2025, and the BPI notes that the year's biggest CD sellers were all new or recent releases, not catalogue. The ERA's retail-spend figures are less positive, showing UK CD spending down 1% to £125.0 million in 2025 (Music Week). Depending on how it's measured, the UK CD market grew slightly or held flat.
Globally, the IFPI Global Music Report 2026 found that physical revenue returned to growth in 2025, up 8.0%, helped by a 13.7% rise in vinyl. Asia was the largest physical region, with 45.1% of global physical revenue.
Who Is Buying: The Album as Merchandise
The single biggest driver is K-pop, and K-pop sells albums differently from other genres. Luminate credits collectible K-pop releases for much of the first-half CD surge, and notes that mass-market retailers took nearly 30% of physical sales "as K-pop fandom drives this retail channel."
The mechanics are well documented. The Korea Times describes albums released in multiple versions and bundled with randomized photocards, which pushes fans to buy several copies to get a particular card or a full set. Fansign lotteries treat each album purchase as an entry, and it is "widely understood within fandoms" that more albums mean better odds. Buying dozens of copies of the same release is common, and some fans buy more than 100. Labels have also redesigned the product itself. One version of ILLIT's November 2025 album was built around a mini doll keychain, with a mini CD tucked inside. The disc has become the delivery method for the collectible.
This model is not limited to Korea. Our earlier piece on Thai pop cited an SCB EIC finding that superfans make up just 1.9% of T-Pop listeners but generate 42% of its revenue, with albums, photo books and random photocards among the things they spend it on. Physical media works well as a fan product because a stream earns the artist a fraction of a cent, while a disc is something the fan can hold and show off.
Western superfans behave in similar ways, though less intensely. Taylor Swift's variant editions drove UK sales of both CDs and vinyl in 2025. Alliance attributes its CD growth to "boxed sets, catalog reissues, and import editions," and its collectibles revenue almost doubled, from $6.4 million to $11.9 million, as packaged media was sold alongside licensed merchandise (Media Play News). As Walker put it, fans who can stream an album "still want something special they can own and collect."
The clearest evidence that the CD is now a collectible: according to Luminate's midyear report, as summarized by Stereogum, about half of Gen Z and Millennial CD buyers do not own a CD player. Luminate's own explanation is that buying physical music "is as much about aesthetic ownership and direct financial support for the artist as it is listening to the music on the product itself."
Why the CD, and Not Just Vinyl
If the point is to own something, the next question is why the cheaper disc is now growing faster than the more fashionable one. Luminate's answer is price: superfans are turning to the CD as "an affordable collectible."
The RIAA's own figures show how big the gap is. Dividing first-half 2026 revenue by units gives an average wholesale value of about $9.80 per CD ($171.1 million / 17.5 million) against about $20.50 per vinyl record ($543.8 million / 26.5 million). These are the author's calculations from RIAA data, at wholesale rather than retail prices, but they show that a vinyl LP costs roughly twice as much as a CD. For a fan buying five versions of one album, that difference adds up quickly. For a teenager with no turntable and no CD player, the cheaper object fills the same role on a shelf.
Japan: The Market Where the CD Never Left
Seen from Tokyo, the "CD comeback" looks strange, because in Japan the CD never went away. In March 2026 the Recording Industry Association of Japan (RIAJ) published its first estimate of combined physical and digital sales, a new series that includes non-member companies and so cannot be compared directly with earlier RIAJ figures. It put Japan's 2025 market at ¥398.8 billion. Physical formats made up 57% and digital 43%, as reported by BCN Retail. CDs alone brought in ¥168.6 billion, more than subscription streaming at ¥137.7 billion. CD album sales rose 21% year on year, while subscription streaming grew 10%. Physical sales also exceeded their 2019 level.
The IFPI's global figures match. Japan, the world's second-largest recorded-music market, returned to growth in 2025 with an 8.9% gain, and Asia accounted for 45.1% of global physical revenue (IFPI). Japan is not "reviving" the CD so much as showing what a stable, fan-driven CD market looks like. Discs bundled with idol-event access and retailer-specific bonuses have long been part of how Japanese fans buy music, a pattern similar to random photocards in K-pop (this is the author's observation; RIAJ's figures do not break out what drives the purchases). The US increasingly resembles that model, with discs bought as tokens of support, not as the main way to listen.
Is DVD Next?
Alliance's 20% rise in DVD and Blu-ray revenue is the basis for the "DVD revival" question in the original article, and the data does not support much of it yet.
According to the Digital Entertainment Group (DEG), as summarized by Luminate, US consumers spent $870 million on DVD, Blu-ray and 4K UHD discs in 2025. That was down 9.3% from 2024 and 85.7% below the $6.1 billion spent in 2015. In 2025, subscription streaming reached $57.5 billion, 92.4% of all US home-entertainment spending. That is still a market in decline.
There are a few positive signs. The 9.3% drop was the smallest decline since 2016, after falls of 20%–25% a year earlier this decade, including 23.4% in 2024 (What Hi-Fi?). Sales of premium 4K UHD discs and collector's editions rose 12%. Luminate concludes that the disc's decline "is at least flattening out" and that a "vinyl-like rebirth into a specialized luxury item" is the likely outcome. That would be a smaller, more expensive niche for collectors, not a return to the mass market.
Alliance's own gains have a specific cause: its exclusive physical-distribution deals with Paramount and Amazon MGM Studios, which brought it new titles and wider retail placement. The 20% rise likely reflects Alliance's growing share of distribution as much as consumer demand (author's inference). For now, "DVD revival" means the decline is slowing, with a premium 4K niche growing inside it.
The Limits: A Small Revival for a Few Artists
The growth figures are real, but they should not be overstated. There are four limits worth keeping in mind.
The base is small. The US CD market's best recent result is still a minor part of the whole. In 2025 the CD's $312.4 million made up about 2.7% of US recorded-music revenue of $11.54 billion (author's calculation from the RIAA). Even after the strong first half of 2026, CDs were under 3% of the US total. A 58.6% gain on that base adds about $63 million, which matters for a distributor like Alliance but barely affects an industry dominated by streaming.
The growth comes from a small number of artists and a lot of repeat buying. CD sales rose 16% overall but only 6.7% without K-pop, which implies that K-pop accounts for more than half of the US CD growth (author's calculation from Luminate's figures). Within K-pop, sales are both concentrated and levelling off. Circle Chart figures cited by The Korea Times show that the top 400 releases sold about 90.9 million units in 2025 through November, below the symbolic 100-million mark for the second year in a row. Stray Kids alone sold nearly 7 million. In the UK, one Taylor Swift album accounted for about 226,000 CDs. When much of the volume comes from fans buying multiple copies, unit sales measure how intense a fan base is more than how many people are buying.
The waste is real, and many of the discs are never played. In 2023, The Korea Times reported Environment Ministry figures obtained by lawmaker Woo Won-shik: K-pop companies used 801.5 tons of plastic for physical albums in 2022, more than 14 times the 55.8 tons used in 2017 (The Korea Times). The fan-led group Kpop4Planet collected more than 8,000 unwanted albums in one campaign and has called for a "green album" option, where fans pay for as many copies as they want but receive only a few physical ones. Luminate's finding that half of young CD buyers own no player suggests many discs are bought as tokens and stored, not listened to.
The money does not reach most artists. Fan-driven physical sales mostly benefit acts that already have large, organised fan bases and labels that can produce multiple versions, photocards and event tie-ins. For most working musicians, who have no fansign lottery and no box set, a CD revival adds little to income (this is the author's inference). The Korea Times also notes that K-pop agencies are moving away from album volume toward concerts and merchandise, with an industry source saying fans increasingly prefer "items that offer practical value rather than purchasing albums simply to boost their favorite singers' rankings." Even the companies best at selling physical albums are not relying on them for growth.
Conclusion: Owning the Music Again, in a Different Sense
The CD's comeback is real but specific. In the US, the format went from shrinking to growing within a year. The UK has stabilised. In Japan, CDs still bring in more than subscription streaming. In all three markets, fans are buying a disc as a souvenir, a vote of support or a lottery ticket, more than as a way to listen. Streaming won the listening, and physical formats are competing for ownership and fan loyalty.
That makes the CD a fan product more than a music format. Its future depends less on new listeners than on how long label strategies built around superfans keep working, and on whether fans, environmental campaigners and the companies themselves start to push back. The DVD faces an even harder version of the same test. Its decline is slowing, but for now the most likely outcome is a smaller, premium niche for collectors, not a mass-market revival.
Sources
- Original article: Ashley King, "CD Sales Continue to Trickle Upward—Is a DVD Revival Next?," Digital Music News, November 13, 2026
- Erik Gruenwedel, "Alliance Entertainment Ups Quarterly Blu-ray Disc, DVD Revenue 20% to $101 Million," Media Play News, November 12, 2026 (Alliance Q1 FY2027 segment revenue, prior-year comparisons, Walker quotes)
- RIAA, 2026 Mid-Year Music Industry Revenue Report (US CD, vinyl and physical revenue and units, H1 2026, wholesale basis)
- RIAA, Year-End 2025 Revenue Report (US CD and vinyl full-year 2025, wholesale basis)
- Luminate, 2026 Midyear Report: Trends in Music, Television & Film (US CD and vinyl consumer unit sales H1 2026, K-pop exclusion, mass-market share)
- Stereogum, "CD Sales Growth Outpaces Vinyl Despite Half of Gen Z, Millennial CD Buyers Not Owning CD Players" (Luminate's CD-player and "affordable collectible" findings; RIAA 2025 mid-year comparison)
- BPI, "New generation of British artists helped UK recorded music market in 2025 surpass £1.5 billion," March 12, 2026 (UK CD and vinyl revenue 2025)
- Music Week, "ERA: UK music streaming subscription income tops £2 billion in 2025 as vinyl sales surge by 18%" (ERA retail-spend figures)
- IFPI, "Global Music Report 2026: Global recorded music revenues grow 6.4%" (global physical growth, Asia's physical share, Japan's 2025 growth)
- BCN Retail, "2025年の音楽ソフト+音楽配信の推計規模は3988億円," March 10, 2026 (RIAJ 2025 sales estimate for Japan)
- The Korea Times, "Why K-pop albums are increasingly resembling merchandise," January 9, 2026 (multi-version albums, photocards, fansign lotteries, Circle Chart 2025 totals)
- The Korea Times, "Plastic use for K-pop albums increases 14 times over last 6 years," October 22, 2023 (plastic use, Kpop4Planet)
- Luminate, "Is DVD the New Vinyl? The Silver Lining to Spiraling Disc Spend" (DEG 2025 US disc spending, 4K UHD growth, SVOD share)
- What Hi-Fi?, "Streaming remains on top, but 4K Blu-ray is making a comeback" (DEG 2024 vs. 2025 disc-sales decline)
- SCB EIC, The New Era of T-Pop: Growth Beyond Thailand (T-Pop superfan revenue share)