Forty Terabytes of Proof: Why Suno and Udio Are Chasing the MLC's Streaming Data

Updated:

On October 30, 2026, a Nashville law firm filed an 18-page brief on behalf of an organization most music fans have never heard of. The Mechanical Licensing Collective — the MLC — asked a federal court in the Middle District of Tennessee to refuse a request from Uncharted Labs, the company behind the AI music generator Udio. Udio wanted roughly five years of month-by-month streaming data from eight services. The MLC's answer, per its opposition filing: pulling it together would take two to three weeks of staff time, produce 35 to 40 terabytes of files, and expose other companies' confidential business information — all for a lawsuit the MLC is not even a party to.

The MLC's dispute with Udio over streaming data is one of several third-party subpoena fights spinning out of the major labels' AI lawsuits

On its face this is a procedural squabble. Underneath, it marks a shift in what the record-label lawsuits against Suno and Udio are about. Earlier coverage on this site traced how rights holders such as the Elvis Presley estate and Eminem's publisher have been building claims against Suno, and how the RIAA is replaying its Napster-era playbook; those stories were about whether the AI companies copied. This one is about what the copying cost — and who has the numbers to prove it.

Who Is Still Suing Whom

Two years into the litigation, the line-up has thinned, which makes it easy to lose track of who is actually still in court.

Udio. Universal Music Group settled with Udio in late October 2025 and announced a licensed AI music platform with it (Music Business Worldwide); Warner Music Group followed on November 19, 2025 (Music Business Worldwide). Sony Music did not settle. It remains a plaintiff in the original case, UMG Recordings v. Uncharted Labs (No. 1:24-cv-03777, S.D.N.Y.) — the case in which Udio issued its subpoena to the MLC, according to the MLC's brief — and in July 2026 it filed a second, larger suit. Udio's August 2026 answer to that second complaint pleads fair use and copyright misuse, and lists licensing deals with UMG, Warner, Merlin, Kobalt, Believe and the NMPA.

Suno. Warner is the only major that has settled with and licensed Suno; its backing underpinned Suno's v6 model launch in September 2026. UMG and Sony are still suing in UMG Recordings v. Suno (No. 1:24-cv-11611, D. Mass.), and UMG filed a second suit in September 2026. Digital Music News reports that a newly approved schedule in the older Massachusetts case runs pre-trial deadlines into June 2027.

Both AI companies are represented by the same lawyer, Chris Campbell of The Campbell Firm, and the MLC says their meet-and-confer talks with it were run jointly. That is why the two subpoena fights look nearly identical.

What Exactly They Asked For

The Udio case has a public docket on CourtListener, so its timeline can be checked against court records rather than press reports:

  • October 1, 2026: Uncharted Labs files a motion to compel in the Middle District of Tennessee (No. 3:26-mc-00020).
  • October 7: Chief Judge William L. Campbell Jr. refers the motion to Magistrate Judge Luke A. Evans.
  • October 19: The MLC flags a related case, Suno, Inc. v. Mechanical Licensing Collective (No. 3:26-mc-00021).
  • October 26: After a nine-minute phone conference, the magistrate judge sets the briefing schedule: MLC response due October 30, Udio's reply due November 13.
  • October 30: The MLC files its opposition along with two declarations.

The request itself, as quoted in the filings, seeks documents "sufficient to show Performance Data for all Labels in Your Database on a monthly basis for the period 2021 to present," for Amazon, Apple, Deezer, Pandora, SoundCloud, Spotify, Tidal and YouTube. Per Digital Music News, "performance data" covers fields such as ISRC, title, label, distributor, play count, use type, match status and featured artists. Suno's first version, served in April, listed 11 services, including Meta, Snapchat and TikTok. The August reissue cut it to the same eight.

Two details show how the AI companies think about this data. First, they offered to pay: the MLC's own lawyers passed along a vendor estimate of about $5,000 in services plus $100 or more per terabyte per month in AWS hosting. Second, they refused to narrow the request to the plaintiff labels only. In a September 23 letter quoted by Digital Music News, Campbell wrote that such a limitation "would defeat a central purpose of the request."

The Suno docket is less clear. Press reports say Suno filed its motion on October 15, that the MLC agreed to respond by November 2, and that Suno's reply is due November 16. As of October 30, though, Digital Music News noted the judge had not approved that schedule. I could not confirm those dates against the court record, so they rest on media reports.

Why AI Companies Want Market Data: The Fourth Factor

The reason two AI startups would go to court for royalty-processing files lies in one line of the Copyright Act. Section 107 lists four factors for fair use. The fourth is "the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work." Courts often treat that factor as the most important.

Generative AI has pushed a new theory into that factor. In Kadrey v. Meta (June 2025), Judge Vince Chhabria ruled for Meta on fair use, but wrote at length about "market dilution": the idea that a model producing floods of competing works could harm the market for the originals even without copying any one of them. He suggested this theory could often decide the fourth factor in plaintiffs' favor. Meta won because the authors had offered almost no evidence of dilution. In other words, the opinion turned on the evidence.

The labels' complaints against Suno and Udio make exactly that kind of argument: AI-generated tracks compete with the recordings they were trained on and dilute the royalty pool. Udio's memorandum, as quoted in the MLC's brief, frames the response as an empirical test: "The truth or falsity of Plaintiff's theory of harm is a question that data can answer — either the appearance of AI-generated music impacted the performance of Plaintiff's sound recordings or it did not." Suno's motion, per Digital Music News, calls the dataset "a comprehensive record of what happened in the music streaming market during the key period when Suno's platform was launched."

That also explains why "all labels" matters to them. A plaintiff's falling market share proves little on its own; it needs a baseline. If independents and DIY distributors moved the same way as the majors, AI is a weak explanation. If only the majors slipped, the labels' story gets stronger. Restricting the data to the plaintiffs removes the comparison group (this is my reading of the AI companies' strategy, not something either has stated in these terms).

There is a second defense in play. Both companies plead copyright misuse: the claim that the majors use their "must-have" catalogs to extract anti-AI terms from streaming services. In its fight with Apple, Suno argued that deal terms such as guaranteed minimum royalties and clauses that exclude AI content from the royalty pool could insulate labels from any real loss. If so, the claimed market harm may never show up in the labels' revenue.

The MLC: The Wrong Ledger, the Right Database

The MLC was created by the Music Modernization Act of 2018. The U.S. Copyright Office designated it in July 2019 as the sole administrator of the blanket mechanical license, and it began operating on the license availability date, January 1, 2021. In June 2026, the Office continued that designation after its first five-year review. (The "2021 to present" window in the subpoenas is not arbitrary: it is the MLC's entire operating history.)

The MLC's central point is that the AI companies have the wrong ledger. The label lawsuits concern sound recordings, which are owned and licensed by record labels. The MLC handles musical works — songs as written, owned by songwriters and publishers. Under the Copyright Office's own guidance, the two are separate copyrights. Streaming services send the MLC monthly usage reports so that songwriters get paid. Under 37 C.F.R. § 210.27, label names go into those reports only "to the extent acquired" by the service, and the MLC's declarant says those fields "are often blank." The MLC also points out that Udio's own lawyers had called the label field "optional and may be spotty."

The rest of the brief makes three arguments:

  1. Availability elsewhere. At a March 12, 2026 hearing in the Suno case, the labels' counsel said they had already produced market-share, royalty and consumption data going back to 2019, plus more than 180 platform agreements. Apple, in its own motion, said it had offered aggregate monthly upload and play data from January 1, 2022 onward. The MLC calls itself a would-be "ninth non-party producing copies of the same underlying data."
  2. Confidentiality. Under 37 C.F.R. § 210.34, data the streaming services send the MLC is their "Confidential Information." The MLC may disclose it in federal litigation only under a court order or subpoena paired with a protective order.
  3. Burden. The estimate: two to three weeks of IT staff time at $150 to $315 an hour; 35 to 40 terabytes of output, compressible to around 10 TB with more work; a specialized AWS transfer; ongoing security monitoring; and DSP-specific copies for each service. For scale, one person-week at those rates comes to about $6,000 to $12,600. The filing doesn't say how many staff would be involved, so the total is open (my calculation).

The MLC's position is uncomfortable, and the correspondence shows it. Emails attached to Suno's motion indicate that the MLC had been preparing to produce the data in mid-2026 and had relayed a cost estimate. It then reversed course after the affected services objected. In July, Pandora's counsel wrote that it "does not consent to any production that includes Pandora data," according to Digital Music News. The MLC depends on the streaming services' reporting to do its job, and it is legally bound to protect that reporting. It cannot hand over a database built on their trust without a court order telling it to.

Apple and the Other Third Parties

The MLC is one of several outside parties pulled in, and Apple is the most prominent. On October 13, Apple moved in the Northern District of California to quash a Suno deposition subpoena. The subpoena sought testimony on four topics: Apple Music's current licensing talks with UMG and Sony, including any AI provisions; whether Apple Music would be commercially viable without the majors' catalogs; streaming fraud; and communications with the plaintiffs and the RIAA about the case.

In a November 4 reply, Apple said it had already responded to six subpoenas from both sides, with "more than 90 emails and more than 10 verbal conferrals," and wrote: "After more than a year of cooperation, Apple respectfully suggests that the time has come to set a limit on the reasonable scope of third-party discovery here." It argued that misuse turns on the plaintiffs' conduct, not Apple's view of their catalogs. It also argued that a protective order cannot keep Apple's negotiating positions away from its counterparties at trial. With Apple not opposing, the magistrate judge then transferred the motion to Massachusetts, where the main Suno case is pending, according to Digital Music News.

The labels are issuing subpoenas too: to DistroKid, and to Suno investors including Lightspeed. Billboard has catalogued every company fighting a subpoena in the Suno case. Taken together, the fights show where the evidence in these cases is. Much of the market data that could prove or disprove harm is held by outside parties — streaming services, distributors, the MLC — rather than by the labels or the AI companies.

How Nonparty Subpoenas Work

Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 45 governs subpoenas to nonparties, and its text explains most of what is happening in Nashville:

  • Who decides. If the recipient objects, the serving party may move "the court for the district where compliance is required" to compel production (Rule 45(d)(2)(B)(i)). The MLC is based in Nashville. That is why the fight is in Tennessee, not New York or Massachusetts.
  • Burden and expense. The party serving a subpoena "must take reasonable steps to avoid imposing undue burden or expense." Any order compelling production "must protect a person who is neither a party nor a party's officer from significant expense." A court must quash a subpoena that imposes "undue burden," and may quash or modify one that requires disclosing "confidential... commercial information."
  • Proportionality. Rule 26(b)(1) limits discovery to what is relevant and "proportional to the needs of the case." Relative access to information and whether the burden outweighs the benefit are part of that test. Courts in the Sixth Circuit, which covers Tennessee, have held that a recipient's nonparty status weighs against disclosure; the MLC cites In re Modern Plastics Corp. (6th Cir. 2018) for that point.
  • Transfer. Under Rule 45(f), the compliance court may send the motion back to the issuing court if the recipient consents or there are "exceptional circumstances." That is the route Apple's motion took to Massachusetts.

Under those rules, the main question for Magistrate Judge Evans is not who wins on fair use. It is whether Udio has shown that the MLC holds something it cannot reasonably get from the labels or the streaming services, and whether that justifies weeks of a nonprofit's time even if Udio pays.

The Case for Caution

Several reasons argue against reading too much into this.

Discovery fights are routine. Large copyright cases produce subpoena disputes as a matter of course. Motions to compel and to quash are how the rules are supposed to work, and neither filing predicts the merits. The MLC itself writes that "whether or not" Udio's theory of harm is right, the MLC is not the place to test it.

The request may be too broad. Every label, eight services, nearly six years, up to 40 terabytes — and the label field that matters most is often empty. Even if the data is produced, it may not support a clean label-by-label market-share analysis. The MLC's sharpest point is Udio's own email saying it wanted to see whether the data "gets us there." Courts generally refuse to let one side search a nonparty's files hoping something useful turns up.

The cost lands on songwriters' administrator. Reimbursement covers the AWS bill. It does not replace weeks in which the MLC's engineers are not matching usage to songs or chasing unclaimed royalties — the work the MMA created the MLC to do. The organization serves songwriters and publishers, who are not parties to these recording lawsuits.

The AI companies have a point too. The labels' production consists of the labels' own data, and Apple's offer starts in 2022. A cross-service record built from usage reports that every service must file, starting in 2021, would let the defense check the plaintiffs' numbers against a source they don't control. Campbell's letter says the MLC confirmed it could produce the data and then changed course. If that is accurate, the burden claim was raised only after the DSPs objected. Both readings are plausible on the current record.

What to Watch

Udio's reply brief is due November 13 under the magistrate judge's order. A ruling could follow on the papers or after a hearing. The Suno motion, now before the same judge, appears to be on a parallel track, though its reported dates are unconfirmed. Apple's motion has moved to Massachusetts. Behind all of it, the Suno case's pre-trial calendar now extends into mid-2027.

The two companies began the litigation defending their training practices. They are now trying to establish whether the AI tracks that reached streaming services took any measurable share from the labels. The data that could answer that question sits in the files of streaming services, distributors and a songwriters' royalty administrator, all of which are reluctant to hand it over. How the courts handle those requests will shape how much evidence on market harm reaches a jury.

Sources