Australia has rejected AI copyright exemptions twice. The music-publishing industry is warning that it's being pushed to try again.
Updated:
The global body representing music publishers has a blunt message for Canberra: Australian artists' work has already been scraped to train AI, and weakening copyright to accommodate AI companies would "legitimize larceny."
John Phelan, Managing Director of the International Confederation of Music Publishers (ICMP), told Australian legislators that tech companies have lobbied "dozens of countries" to dilute copyright for AI training — and that Australia is now "the only one seriously considering it" (Digital Music News). Phelan said hits from Kylie Minogue and Nick Cave have already been used to train AI models without compensation or permission, and accused tech firms of trying to "strong-arm Australian policymakers into 'if you don't do this, we won't invest'" (Digital Music News).
The claim that doesn't quite fit the record
The warning arrives, oddly, after two years in which Australia moved in the opposite direction. In October 2025, Attorney-General Michelle Rowland announced the government "will not be entertaining a text and data mining exception" for AI — a rejection the industry greeted as a win for "cultural sovereignty," in the words of APRA AMCOS CEO Dean Ormston (Billboard). In July 2026, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese went further, saying in a speech at the University of Sydney: "No company should use Australian books, music, art or news to build or train AI without the artist's control... Anything less, is theft," pledging that the law "will spell that out plain as day" (Billboard).
So what re-opened the question? The immediate trigger, per DMN, is a joint letter to the prime minister from Jo Briskey and Senator Jonathon Duniam — the labor chair and deputy chair of a government AI inquiry — recommending the government re-examine current copyright law while ensuring creators retain control and receive compensation (Digital Music News). Read closely, that recommendation is about reviewing the framework's operation, not endorsing a U.S.-style fair-use carve-out. But for an industry that watched 62 countries consider similar proposals and saw "not a single country" among them introduce a commercial text-and-data-mining exception, per Phelan, any reopening of the question is a red line (Digital Music News). ICMP represents publishers accounting for roughly 90% of the world's commercially released music, from UMPG and Sony Music Publishing to BMG, Kobalt and Concord (Billboard).
The leverage: withholding models, and a 12-million-song dataset
The pressure campaign has a specific shape. AI companies have withheld their frontier models from the Australian market while copyright rules remain unchanged — a withholding Phelan characterizes as deliberate leverage (Digital Music News).
And the "already happening" argument has teeth. Phelan cited an AI training dataset revealed over the summer containing more than 12 million songs scraped from YouTube, including hits from major Australian artists (Digital Music News). The pattern is global: in the United States, AI developers have trained on copyrighted music without compensation while relying on fair-use defenses that remain untested in court.
"The world is very much watching what Australia does," Phelan said. The counter-pressure is equally explicit: investment is the carrot, model access is the stick, and the industry's bet is that a country which twice said no won't say yes the third time the question is asked.
Sources
- Digital Music News — Elephant In the Room Reminder: Major Hits from Kylie Minogue and Nick Cave Already Used to Train AI Without Compensation, the ICMP Tells Australian Legislators (Michael Whalen), October 19, 2026
- Billboard — Australia Government Shuts Down Copyright Exemptions for AI Training, October 27, 2025
- Billboard — Australian Prime Minister Commits to AI Copyright Protections for Artists, July 15, 2026
- Billboard — ICMP Welcomes Australian Government's 'Landmark' Statement on AI, July 16, 2026